So, there’s a good chance I’ll be taking a trip down to the Caribbean next January. I’m wondering which places you, lovely readers, like best. I know I missed islands, so if I missed your favorite island, please list it. Thanks!
Now tell me what your idea of paradise is below . . .
wayward-bound.com 
for other i choose Isla Roatan for the best Caribbean Island
In Honduras? I’ve always wanted to go there. Well, there and Utila. It’s on my Places To Go list. Thanks for responding!
It looks as from your current posts you have decided on Puerto Rico. Roatan is beautiful but as a major spot for cruise ships it is a bit commercial. Gourgous non the less but I think your choice of Puerto Rico will offer some amazing sights and culture. Have a fun vacation!